12 Reasons BJ’s is Better Than Costco

Shopping at wholesale clubs has become an integral part of the American household, offering a wide range of products at discounted prices.

Costco operates 610 stores throughout the United States, surpassing BJ’s, which has 256 stores on the East Coast.

While Costco often receives much attention for its scale and popularity, BJ’s Wholesale Club offers its own set of compelling advantages that might make it a better choice for many consumers. Here’s why BJ’s could be a superior shopping destination than Costco.

More Convenient Locations

Image Credit: John New, Shutterstock

For many shoppers, the proximity of a store is a crucial factor in deciding where to shop. BJ’s tends to be more prevalent in certain regions where Costco has a limited presence, particularly on the East Coast.

This geographical advantage means that for many, BJ’s is simply more accessible than Costco. The convenience of having a store nearby cannot be overstated, especially when it comes to buying bulk items that may be cumbersome to transport.

Lower Membership Fees

Image Credit: Photoroyalty, Shutterstock

One of the most immediate benefits of BJ’s compared to Costco is the lower membership cost.

BJ’s offers a basic annual membership that is generally cheaper than Costco’s equivalent. This lower entry price makes BJ’s an attractive option for those who are unsure about fully committing to the bulk purchase lifestyle or for smaller households that might not spend enough to justify the higher fee at Costco.

More Payment Options

Image Credit: Andrii Iemelianenko, Shutterstock

BJ’s accepts a wider variety of payment methods compared to Costco, which can be a significant convenience factor for many shoppers.

While Costco has an exclusive partnership with Visa, BJ’s accepts all major credit cards, including MasterCard, Visa, Discover, and American Express. This flexibility allows shoppers to use their preferred credit card, taking advantage of any rewards or cash back that their specific cards offer.

Coupon Policies

Worried woman looking at a calculator and holding a credit card at her home
Image Credits: Deposit Photos

BJ’s stands out with its more flexible coupon policy. Unlike Costco, BJ’s accepts manufacturer’s coupons in addition to their store coupons. This can lead to substantial savings for shoppers who take the time to clip coupons or who use digital coupon services. The ability to stack various discounts can turn already low prices into steals, providing a significant advantage for budget-conscious consumers.

Store Layout and Size

Image Credit: Angelo Cordeschi, Shutterstock

The layout and size of BJ’s stores are often cited as being more manageable than those of Costco. BJ’s locations tend to be slightly smaller, which can make for a quicker and less overwhelming shopping experience.

Shoppers can find what they need without the sometimes daunting scale of Costco’s warehouses, which can be particularly appealing for those who prefer a more straightforward shopping trip.

Product Variety and Store Brands

Image Credit: Deposit Photos

While both clubs offer a wide range of products, BJ’s has been noted for having a broader selection in certain categories such as organic and natural foods, baby supplies, and pet products.

Furthermore, BJ’s store brands, such as Berkley Jensen and Wellsley Farms, provide high-quality alternatives to national brands at a fraction of the price. These brands often receive high marks for quality and value, competing favorably with both Costco’s Kirkland Signature products and mainstream brands.

Gas Prices

Image Credit: Amorn Suriyan, Shutterstock

For those with vehicles, the cost of gas is an ever-present concern. BJ’s typically offers very competitive prices on gasoline, similar to Costco. However, an advantage BJ’s holds is that its gas stations often have shorter lines compared to Costco, where waiting times can be significant, especially during peak hours.

Time is money, and saving time while filling up can be just as valuable as saving a few cents per gallon.

Smaller Bulk Quantities

Image Credit: BearFotos, Shutterstock

BJ’s offers smaller bulk quantities than Costco, which is ideal for smaller households or those with limited storage space. This differentiation means shoppers don’t have to commit to purchasing extremely large quantities of products, reducing waste and the upfront financial outlay.

For those who value bulk savings but have smaller needs, BJ’s hits the sweet spot.

Online and Mobile Shopping Experience

Image Credit: Deposit Photos

BJ’s has invested heavily in its online presence and mobile app, providing a robust platform for shoppers who prefer to buy online. Their app includes features such as the ability to create shopping lists, use digital coupons, and even select a pick-up time for curbside pickup services.

The user-friendly nature of BJ’s digital tools enhances the shopping experience for tech-savvy consumers and adds a layer of convenience that complements their in-store offerings.

Exclusive Member and Optical Services

Image Credit: mentatdgt, Shutterstock

BJ’s offers a range of exclusive member services, including home and auto insurance, vacation packages, and home improvement programs. These services provide added value that goes beyond the typical wholesale shopping experience.

BJ’s also provides in-store optical services at many locations, offering affordable eye exams, glasses, and contact lenses. This can be a convenient and cost-effective solution for members needing optical care.

Free Trial and Flexible Membership Options

Image Credit: wavebreakmedia, Shutterstock

BJ’s differentiates itself by offering a free trial membership, which allows potential members to experience the benefits of the club without any upfront investment. This trial period is a unique opportunity for shoppers to explore BJ’s extensive product selection and member perks before committing to a paid membership.

Additionally, BJ’s offers a variety of membership types to suit different needs and budgets, including a one-day pass that lets customers shop without a long-term commitment. This flexibility is particularly appealing to those who are new to warehouse club shopping or who are unsure if the bulk purchase model fits their lifestyle.

Better Access to Sales and Clearance Items

Image Credit: Drazen Zigic, Shutterstock

BJ’s is known for having more frequent sales and a wider variety of clearance items than Costco. This can be a significant advantage for shoppers looking to find the best deals. BJ’s often includes high-value items in their clearance sections, including electronics and seasonal goods, which can be purchased at a substantial discount.

Additionally, BJ’s regularly cycles its inventory through sales, offering weekly promotions that help shoppers save on various products more often. This inventory management approach provides opportunities for savings and keeps the shopping experience fresh and exciting.

Scroll to Top